It is funny how much more unmuddled things become when you drop your wizardry and become a muggle, I also remember how I used to try and overcomplicate things and then opted for the oversimplified bible answer to tough questions as I tried to make the bible fit what I thought anyway...
Take this for example: If you simply frame this in regards to personal liberty the counter to this is simple: Each person has complete control over what happens to their own body. If someone wants to die, they should be free to die. However this choice cannot be forced upon them.
Exactly and many depressed and bankrupt people already jump off buildings, or find other ways of offing themselves, but euthanasia for terminally ill people isn't just about killing yourself, it's minimizing the pain of the terminally ill person and it's for the benefit of your loved ones not having to clean up after you, after having been with and shared your pain, to clean up your brain matter and to deal with that whole ugly sight on top of having to deal with what the cancer has already done to you.
When you are dying of cancer you start to think a lot about the life and people you will leave behind and this differs from depressed people who I reckon focus more on their own issues while still having a glimmer of hope for things to change.
So, the assumption being made can be said to be invalid: What's immoral about suicide in the first place?
Don't you know? Because of the bible and you'll go to Hell
